Changing the narrative: how the claims industry can attract the new generation of talent
4th June 2025
Tweet
At ILC’s New Generation in Claims Discovery Day, held at UCAS headquarters in Cheltenham, the spotlight turned toward the future of the insurance claims sector.
Under the banner of Momentum: Learn – Collaborate – Move, and in collaboration with Consumer Intelligence and UCAS, industry leaders gathered to tackle a pressing issue: the urgent need to rebrand insurance claims as an attractive, impactful career choice for young people.
The keynote speaker, Ian Hughes, CEO of Consumer Intelligence, delivered a provocative session that laid bare the sector’s public perception – and its consequences. With stark honesty, Ian unpacked recent research into how young people perceive the industry, presenting a challenge to the assembled professionals: either shift how the sector is marketed or risk losing a generation of talent.
Understanding the perception gap
Ian opened with a jolt of realism: “Your customers today are young people trying to decide their future – and they don’t want to work for you.”
Drawing on fresh research from UCAS applicants and a broader general population (Gen Pop) cohort, Ian revealed an uncomfortable truth: insurance and claims are seen as some of the least desirable career options available to young people.
“When we asked if they’d consider a career in insurance, the only thing they wanted to do less was pour concrete,” Ian said bluntly.
The findings showed particularly negative views among UCAS applicants, who were more likely to associate the sector with monotony, bureaucracy, and ethical ambiguity. One respondent even wrote: “It feels cruel to try my best to ruin people’s lives by cutting corners and denying them money they need.”
Such perceptions, Ian argued, aren’t just inaccurate – they’re harmful. “They think you’re boring, bureaucratic, and unethical. And if we don’t change that narrative, we won’t get the talent we need.”
Claims: an industry with impact
Despite the bleak survey responses, Ian was clear in his belief that claims professionals make a real difference. Recounting a recent drive along the M4, where he witnessed a serious car crash, he used it as a poignant example of the sector’s role during people’s worst days.
“That family was having the worst day of their lives. And without insurance, it would be much worse. What you do matters. It’s not boring. It’s lifesaving,” he said.
Yet, the industry isn’t telling that story. Instead, it’s bogged down in outdated communication and uninspiring imagery. “You’ve got images of bent metal and desk jobs. Meanwhile, other sectors show smiling people walking hand-in-hand,” he pointed out. “No wonder students are running the other way.”
What young people actually want
So, what does the next generation want from a career?
Purpose, progression, flexibility, and support topped the list. Ian highlighted that Gen Z seeks work that aligns with their values and offers a clear pathway for growth. Interestingly, priorities differed slightly by gender – salary and benefits mattered more to men, while women valued job security and supportive environments.
“University is just the next step,” Ian said. “You’re offering a life. But are you making that clear?”
One of the most powerful moments came when Ian removed his jacket and tie mid-presentation, shifting into a more relaxed, authentic style. “I haven’t changed who I am. I’ve just changed how you see me. That’s what this industry needs to do.”
Marketing that works
Ian stressed that perception isn’t just a recruitment problem – it’s a marketing problem. The industry must stop communicating like it’s drafting policy documents.
“Stop writing job descriptions like they’re terms and conditions,” he said. “Young people want clarity, simplicity, and impact. You’ve got all that – you’re just not showing it.”
He laid out five actionable takeaways for the sector:
- Increase visibility – Not just of your company, but of the entire claims sector
- Speak authentically – Drop the jargon. Use real language that resonates
- Emphasise purpose and impact – Make it clear that claims professionals help people, every single day
- Simplify the message – Ditch the complexity. Get straight to the value
- Empower participation – Show young people they can shape the future of the industry from day one
Wake-up call
The session was a powerful wake-up call for a sector that risks being misunderstood out of relevance. Ian’s message was clear: the insurance claims industry doesn’t need to change what it does – it needs to change how it’s seen.
“You don’t need to change who you are,” Ian concluded. “But if you don’t start showing your value in a way that resonates with young people, you will make no impact.”
As ILC’s New Generation in Claims initiative continues, the challenge now lies with industry leaders, HR teams, and marketers to rise to this moment. If they do, there’s a real opportunity to secure a passionate, purpose-driven generation ready to make their mark.
ILC’s New Generation in Claims programme is supported by Ambassadors: Activate Group, Ageas, Carpenters Group, Crawford, e2e, Enterprise, esure, Gemini ARC, Howden, Innovation Group, Kennedys, NWVA, Policy Expert, Repairify, S&G Response, Solera Audatex, VW Group UK, and Zurich Insurance.
Tweet
UPCOMING EVENT
Property Claims Event 2026
26 November 2026














































