Pearson Ham Analysis Shows Premium Finance Costs Fall

Pearson Ham, a specialist pricing consultancy in the insurance and other markets, reports that the cost of financing insurance premiums – the additional charge for paying in monthly instalments – has fallen since its last review in October 2024.

Motor insurance

The typical motor insurance finance cost has eased to just over 10% on average in April 2025, which is 0.6 percentage points lower than six months ago and roughly 1 percentage point lower than April 2024​.

For the motor insurance sector, premium finance interest rates now range from as low as 1.7% to around 20.1%. However, almost all car insurers (around 95% of them) charge between 5% and 15% for customers to pay monthly​. Not a single motor insurance provider currently offers a universally interest-free instalment plan – every product carries a fee or interest – although some companies do give lower rates to customers with strong credit histories.

Home insurance

The latest April 2025 data reveal that the average finance charge across the home insurance market now stands at around 8.1%, having decreased by about 0.5 percentage points in the last six months and by 1.3 points since April 2024. The median charge has seen an even sharper decline, dropping from about 10.0% in October 2024 to 8.6% in April 2025.

Stephen Kennedy of Pearson Ham explained:

“This narrowing gap between the median and average indicates that more insurers are lowering their rates, reducing the skew previously seen when only a few low-cost offerings pulled the average down while most providers charged well above it.”

Growth in low rate offerings

A notable number of home insurers offer low or even zero-percent finance deals. Out of 79 home insurance products surveyed, 14 did not charge any extra for paying in instalments​. Further, more than a quarter of home insurance providers have an average finance rate below 5%​.

However, home insurance also sees some of the highest premium finance charges on the market. The top end reaches 29% APR.

Overall, roughly two-thirds of home insurers charge under 10% for monthly payments, making home policy instalments generally cheaper than those for car insurance.

Cuts in premium finance pricing

Since the previous release in October, many insurers have adjusted their premium finance pricing.

Importantly, several major brands cut the cost of monthly payments for both motor and home insurance over the past six months​. These reductions by well-known insurers have contributed to the market-wide drop in average charges, easing the burden on customers who choose to spread their payments.

Conversely, a smaller handful of providers bucked the trend by implementing slight increases to their instalment charges during the same period​.

Credit availability

Another key development is a tightening of credit availability for insurance instalment plans. Fewer insurance brands are now willing to offer pay-monthly options to all customers without exception.

Since October 2024, the number of motor insurance products with a 100% credit acceptance rate (i.e. available to every customer) has dropped from 81 to 75​.

Home insurance providers have become more selective as well, with the count of products guaranteeing credit to everyone falling from 52 to 46 in the same period​. In practice, this means some customers – particularly those with weaker credit profiles – may no longer be eligible for a monthly payment plan with certain insurers.

Pearson Ham’s analysis suggests that insurers appear to be focusing their best rates and offers on customers deemed lower risk, in order to keep finance costs competitive for those who qualify.

Frances Luery of Pearson Ham Group commented:

“Our latest data shows a clear drop in what insurers are charging for monthly payments, which is good news for consumers. However, we’re also seeing insurers become more picky about who gets to pay monthly. In effect, they’re offering better deals but to a narrower group – favouring customers with stronger credit. It’s a balancing act between competitiveness and risk management, and it will be interesting to see how this plays out in the coming months.”


UPCOMING EVENT

Property Claims Event 2026

26 November 2026

Insurer Partners

Industry Body Partners

Insights Partners