Market Intelligence: Legal – claimant 

ILC ARTICLE

Donna Scully, Director and Owner of Carpenters Group, discussed the current and future legal complexities for claimants, insurers, and regulatory bodies at the Exclusive Motor Claims Conference, hosted recently by ILC. 

The event took place at Landing Forty-Two in London, supported by Headline Partner Enterprise Mobility along with ILC Motor Corporate Partners: Activate Group; AkzoNobel; Autoglass; BHR Assist; CAPS; Carpenters group; Copart; DAC Beachcroft; e2e; Entegral; Enterprise Mobility; Gemini ARC; GT Motive; Innovation Group; Kennedys; National Windscreens; Proclaim Care; S&G Response; Solera Audatex; Synectics Solutions; Synetiq; Verisk; and Whichrate; as well as Claims Essentials Fraud Specialist Partner Robertsons; Sponsor Edam Group; and Reception Sponsor Hawkins.  

Donna began by outlining the implications of the new Labour government’s approach to civil justice, highlighting the significance of key appointments.  

She said, “We have a new Lord Chancellor who is a lawyer and a new head of the Justice Select Committee, Andy Slaughter, also a legal professional. This suggests that the government is placing knowledgeable individuals in critical roles, which could shape the direction of ongoing reforms.”  

The appointments were cause for cautious optimism, she said, but noted the uncertainty regarding whether the new government would prioritise civil justice reforms, given other pressing issues such as criminal justice and prison management.  

She said the issue may be ‘far down the pecking order,’ despite the sector still dealing with the backlog left by the previous administration, particularly in areas like whiplash reforms and the Official Injury Claim (OIC) portal.  

Whiplash tariff review  

A key point of discussion was the whiplash tariff review, which was due just as the election was called. Donna questioned whether any substantial work had been completed by the outgoing government and whether Labour would build upon or restart these efforts.  

She said, “We know the tariff review was supposed to be published, but the election intervened. Have they really done the work, or will the new government start from scratch?” 

She also pointed out the upcoming discount rate review, which the Lord Chancellor has now commenced and will determine the rate no later than 11 January 2025, drawing parallels with recent changes in Northern Ireland and Scotland and speculating that if the UK follows a similar path it could bring stability and predictability to the market.  

This, she said, would be welcomed by the industry, especially given the current ‘economic volatility’. 

Court backlogs 

Meanwhile, addressing the issue of court backlogs, Donna highlighted the significant delays affecting the resolution of small claims. She explained how these delays create a ripple effect, impacting policyholders and insurance companies alike.  

“Currently, small claims are taking over a year to reach a hearing,” she said, “This not only affects customers but also impacts insurers’ ability to reserve appropriately and manage premium renewals.”  

She criticised the current system’s inefficiencies, particularly the reliance on centralised processing, which delays the issuance of notices and prolongs the litigation timeline, and called for a concerted industry effort to lobby for improvements in civil court processing.  

The OIC portal 

Donna also reflected on the three-year anniversary of the OIC portal, describing it as a project that has seen significant investment but remains fraught with challenges.  

“We’ve invested millions into making it work, and while it has improved, life cycles are still increasing, and the system remains burdensome for users,” she admitted.  

Despite these issues, she acknowledged the progress made and stressed the importance of ongoing collaboration with the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) to refine the system. She said the end goal had to be shorter claims life cycles and a smoother process for all users, highlighting the importance of legal expense insurance as a key element in supporting claimants through the complexities of the portal.  

  AI and fraud  

Looking ahead, Donna predicted further consolidation within the motor claims market, driven by the pressures of compliance, regulation, and economic constraints. 

She added that AI would also play a significant role in shaping future processes, and while she acknowledged its potential to streamline operations, she also expressed concern about its misuse.  

She said, “AI is a double-edged sword — it can enhance efficiency, but it can also be exploited by bad actors, particularly in fraud cases.” 

To manage these risks, Donna emphasised the need for combining human expertise with technological advancements.  

She concluded, “We need great people and technology working together. Technology can handle the routine tasks, but it’s people who make the critical decisions and create value.” 


UPCOMING EVENT

Property Claims Event 2026

26 November 2026

Motor Claims News

Daily Motor News – Friday 13 November 2026  

ILC News | Motor | Motor Repair

13-11-2026

Daily Motor News – Thursday 12 November 2026 

ILC News | Motor | Motor Repair

12-11-2026

Belron UK achieves EcoVadis Silver Medal

Claims Tech | Environment | ILC News | Insurance | Mobility | Motor | Motor Repair | People | Supplier | Technology

12-11-2026

Daily Motor News – Wednesday 11 November 2026 

ILC News | Motor | Motor Repair

11-11-2026

Insurer Partners

Industry Body Partners

Insights Partners

Motor Corporate Partners

ACTIVATE GROUP
BHR Assist Insurance Services
INNOVATION-GROUP